Perfect BBQ Pulled Pork: Recipes & Tips
So my friends, I am sharing with you our recipe for Perfect Pulled Pork today, which is just the ticket for all the upcoming Fourth of July festivities and entertaining you’ll be doing this summer.
But first, the backstory; cuz you know I’m all about the backstory. We spent 10 years living in a suburb of Nashville, Tennessee. Both of my babies were born there and we have nothing but very fond memories of that town. We were there when Garth Brooks was taking country music by storm and when Keith Urban was just being ‘discovered’. We lived 5 minutes from Waylon Jennings’ home and my kids grew up singing ‘Only Daddy That’ll Walk the Line’ like other kids grow up singing ‘Itsy Bitsy Spider.’
Nashville is a great foodie town and living in Nashville also spoiled us with all the great barbecue offerings available. There was a little, hole in the wall barbecue restaurant 3 miles from our home that we frequented often and always when friends and family were in town. Sadly, that little barbecue restaurant (Herbert’s) is no longer there, but then again, neither are we! All this to say, my family loves their baby back ribs and pulled pork AND we have very high standards.
When I worked at Williams-Sonoma several years ago it seems like everyone ended up with a Williams-Sonoma gift under the Christmas tree. One Christmas, Terry was gifted with a smoker box for our gas grill in the hopes that we might be able to replicate Herbert’s pulled pork. Ever since then we’ve been working to perfect our smoked and pulled pork. Our first efforts were ‘eh’, but we persevered and now have it down to a science. Making a great pulled pork really isn’t difficult, it just takes time. It’s not the kind of meal that you can decide in the morning to make for dinner that night. It does take a little forethought, but it is worth every bit of that advance planning. And I’ll make a disclaimer right here…if you have a dedicated smoker or are a barbecue purists, you will see no need for finishing in the crock pot. However, after several different tries, we are more than willing to throw bbq traditions to the wind because this is some outstanding pulled pork. Here are our suggestions for perfect pulled pork.
Tips for Perfect Pulled Pork
- Since we don’t have a dedicated smoker, we use our gas grill and it works just fine. Without a smoker, you will need a smoker box. You put your wet wood chips in the box over your heat element and the smoke comes out the perforations in the box. We like Hickory, but Weber makes Applewood, Pecan, Mesquite and Cherrywood. If you don’t have a smoker box, you can make one with aluminum foil as shown here.
- You need a thermometer that can stay in your grill. We have one built in to our grill, but use a second just to be sure.
- You will also need a meat thermometer.
- Soak your woodchips at least 15 minutes before you put them in your smoker box. Tip: it’s better to use too few than too many chips in your smoker box. Ideally you will have a single layer that you will replenish or replace a couple of time throughout the day. We just keep chips soaking in water next to our grill. We also keep a small aluminum trash can to discard the burnt chips that are no longer smoking. When they are completely black, discard them. We discard the blackened chips about 3-4 time during the 12-15 hour smoking period.
- Plan to start the process 48-72 hours before you plan to eat it. There is very little hands on time; however, during the time your pork is on the grill, you do need to be around to make sure that the temperature is remaining constant at 225° and to replenish or replace your wet wood chips.
- Here’s our schedule when making our pulled pork:
Morning 2 days before you plan to eat your pulled pork…Brine (recipe below) your pork shoulder
Morning 1 day before you plan to eat your pulled pork …Coat pork with Rub(recipe below) and place it on your grill with smoker box
Evening 1 day before you plan to eat your pulled pork…Take pork from grill after 12-15 hours of smoking at 225° and put it in your slow cooker or crock-pot on low (with balls of aluminum foil to prevent pork from resting in liquid) with a can of beer and a tablespoon of liquid smoke.
Your pork will be finished late morning or early afternoon on the day you want to eat it. Pull it apart with forks and put it in a lidded container in your refrigerator, with the defatted liquid from crockpot. I separate the fat from the liquid using one of my fav kitchen gadgets...a fat/grease separator. Your biggest challenge now will be keeping fingers out of the container of deliciousness that is beckoning from your refrigerator.
Heat your pulled pork just before you serve it.
- One 7-9 pound pork shoulder
- Brine (Recipe below)
- Rub (Recipe below)
- Smokey Barbecue Sauce (Recipe below)
- Between 48-72 hours before you plan to eat your pulled pork, brine it using the recipe below.
- 36 hours before you plan to eat your pulled pork, soak 2 cups of dried wood chips in water and coat your pork with the rub as described in the rub recipe.
- Warm up one side of grill so that grill temperature is 225'
- Put wood chips in your smoker box or an aluminum foil pouch as described above and put on grill over the elements that are on or coals that are lit.
- Place pork shoulder directly on a grate on the side of grill that does not have the direct heat underneath it.
- Check your grill frequently to make sure that temperature is staying around 225'.
- You want the internal temperature of the grill to reach 195'. Our experience is that even after being on the grill for 12-15 hours. the temperature is usually around 160'. At that point we take it off of the grill and put it in a crockpot on top of 5 aluminum foil balls to keep it from resting on the bottom of the crockpot.
- Pour 1 can of beer into crock pot, but not on top of pork. Add 1 Tablespoon of liquid smoke to beer.
- Turn crockpot on low for 12 hours.
- Pork is usually ready about 12 hours after it has been put in crockpot.
[bctt tweet=”Need the perfect #bbq pulled #pork #recipe for summer #cookouts? Look no further! ” username=”nourish_nestle”]
- 2 quarts of water
- 1 1/2 cups kosher salt
- 1 cup maple syrup or molasses
- 1/2 cup cider vinegar
- Place salt, molasses and 2 cups of the water in a pot and heat up until salt begins to dissolve.
- Add remaining water and vinegar.
- Pour mixture over pork in a large pot with a lid.
- Place pork in refrigerator for a minimum of 12 hours or up to 48 hours.
- 1/4 cup dark brown sugar
- 2 TB smoked paprika
- 2 TB chili powder
- 2 TB dry mustard
- 1 TB salt
- 2 tsp garlic powder
- 1 tsp celery salt
- 1 tsp cumin
- Mix all rub ingredients together.
- With pork fat side down on your cutting board, coat as much of the shoulder with the rub as you can.
- Place shoulder fat side up on your grill and coat the fat side with the remaining rub.
- 1 cup ketchup
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/4 cup vinegar
- 2 Tablespoons dark brown sugar
- 1/2 Tablespoon onion powder
- 1/2 Tablespoon ground powdered mustard
- 1 Tablespoon lemon juice
- 1 Tablespoon liquid smoke
- 1 Tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
- Mix all ingredients in a sauce pan and let simmer for one hour.
- Will keep in refrigerator for 3 months.
Thanks again for stopping by today. I really do appreciate your company more than you’ll ever know and hope you’ll stop by again soon. If you want to make sure you don’t miss future content, pop your email in the beige box up on the right. I usually send out 2-3 emails a week, so I won’t inundate your inbox.
Right now, subscribers to Nourish and Nestle will receive a free, downloadable Measuring Equivalents Chart overlaid on a watercolor lemon. You can see it here. Sign up to our email list (on my right sidebar) and we’ll send it to your inbox within 24 hours! If you are already a subscriber and would like a lemon measuring equivalents chart, send us an email with ‘lemon chart’ in the subject line and we’ll send you one too!