How to Restore an Old Wood Cutting Board
I’ll show you how easy it is to restore an old wood cutting board. We’ll walk through how to clean a wooden cutting board, how to sanitize a wood cutting board, how to sand a wooden cutting board and how to condition and refinish a wooden cutting board.
I am not one of those who usually gets lucky in thrift stores or garage sales. I have a friend who has an incredible thrift store radar…but she hasn’t shared it with me yet (Sherry…I’m looking at you!)
On a recent thrift store foray, when I had a list of items that I was looking for that included an old wooden cutting board…guess what I found?
A thick, edge-grain cutting board…with feet nevertheless. With a 14″ diameter and 1 1/2″ thick, it’s a great size.
And it was only $10.00…that really never happens to me.
It showed signs of use and was quite sticky, but I was excited to bring it home and restore it.
So, how do you restore an old wood cutting board whose history you know nothing about?
Some of these are affiliate links and I will earn a small commission off of the sale of these products, but the price you are charged is not affected. You can see my full disclosure policy here.
How to restore a wooden cutting board: Sanding the cutting board
- The first step is to sand it down. To the question, can you sand a cutting board? The answer is absolutely yes! Sanding the cutting board is a critical first step in the refinishing process. When thinking about how to sand a wooden cutting board, I thought I should use a medium grit (#100) sandpaper first. Once I had all the existing finish off the top, sides, and feet, I then used a fine grit (#220) sandpaper to smooth it down further. For the fine sandpaper, I used my orbital palm sander. I wasn’t interested in removing all the scratches and cuts…I like the character they add.
- I wish you could feel it at this stage…truly felt smooth as satin.
How to sanitize a wood cutting board:
- Because I didn’t know the history of this cutting board, (i.e. whether it had been used to cut meat or poultry) I needed to sanitize it before I could use it.
- Bleach wasn’t an option I wanted to use, so instead I used the less caustic hydrogen peroxide. I placed the cutting board in my sink and covered it with hydrogen peroxide and let the peroxide sit until it stopped fizzing then scrubbed the surface with a scrub brush. This is an important step when you restore an old wood cutting board. If you are more comfortable using bleach, I have read that you can use a diluted solution (2 TBs/gallon of water) of bleach to sanitize your wooden boards.
- It was interesting that each time I poured the hydrogen peroxide, it would fizz in the same area.
- I repeated this process until the hydrogen peroxide no longer fizzed…which was 4 times at which I was comfortable moving on to the next steps in how to sanitize the wood cutting board.
- Then I poured white vinegar over the whole board and sprinkled baking soda over it. With a scrub brush I scrubbed the entire board; top, bottom, and sides.
- I rinsed it and let it dry for 24 hours.
- Once it was all clean and dry, I hit it again with the orbital sander with fine sandpaper. All the cleaning revealed a few areas that I missed from the initial sanding.
How to condition and refinish a wooden cutting board:
- Now for the fun part. I used some existing butcher block conditioner that I have John Taylor Butcher Block Conditioner and my hands and applied the conditioner over the entire board…top and bottom. The old wooden cutting board soaked up the first application of the conditioner in no time, so I repeated it again about 2 hours later and let the board sit overnight. In the morning I used a paper towel to rub off any of the conditioner that hadn’t been absorbed…which wasn’t much. The best way to tell if you have enough conditioner or oil on your cutting board is to drop a few drops of water on it and see if it beads up.
TA DA….and that’s how easy it is to refinish and restore an old wood cutting board…took me part of a day and most of that time was the cutting board soaking or drying.
I may use this cutting board more as a serving piece than an actual cutting board. Pop on over here to see ideas for displaying cutting boards in your kitchen.
By the way, do you ever have just meat and cheese for dinner? It’s one of our favorite meals…and a tradition on Christmas tree decorating day. We vary the meats and cheeses but do like some sweet and savory jams with whatever we decide upon. This savory onion jam and spiced cranberry conserve are our current favorites.
See that hammered copper pot in the background? It was another one of my thrift store finds…but I couldn’t tell you if it was a good deal or not.
Oh, I almost forgot…this cutting board has a little…something on the bottom…not sure what to call it.
The only thing I can think of is that it is for a big butcher type knife. What do you think?
If you love this big chunky round cutting board but haven’t happened upon one in the thrift store to refurbish, I did see that you can get a new one on Amazon.
How about a little before and after action!
If you might want to refinish and restore an old wood cutting board, make sure you pin this image or bookmark the page for your future reference.
Thanks again for spending a few minutes of your busy day with me today. Know that you are appreciated and that I welcome each and every comment that comes my way. If you want to make sure you don’t miss future content, pop your email in the beige box up on the right or click here. I usually send out 2-3 emails a week, so I won’t inundate your inbox…believe me, I’m sensitive to an overflowing email inbox!
Printables and knit patterns are available to all of my subscribers in the Subscriber Benefits Library. I will continue to add patterns and printables to this page as we go along.
So, if you’d like to get in on the ‘subscriber benefit’ action, simply subscribe to Nourish and Nestle using the form on the right sidebar. It’s towards the top a bit. I have sent all my subscribers the link to the Subscriber Benefits Library, but if you missed it or misplaced it, drop me a line.
Hugs,
I would say that your thrifting radar was on target with this wonderful find. I would have snatched it up also. I love that this board has feet and you can use it in so many ways besides for cutting food. Thanks for the great tutorial on how to restore a cutting board and I hope that I can find one as great as this one.
Hey Sherry, coming from you that’s quite a compliment! I would still love to spend time thrifting with you…let’s plan it!
Great find! I am always hesitant to buy thrift store cutting boards, for the very reason of not knowing its’ history. Surely, now that I know how to restore one, it will be months before I find one!
Hey Maureen…Just a fun fact that plastic cutting boards actually hold on to bacteria more than wooden ones! There was a UC Davis research study that discovered that. And if you are nervous, then use a diluted bleach/water solution. Those old pieces just have so much more character!
Hugs my friend.
Lynn
Great tutorial! Beautiful find! Congratulations! You make me want to go thrifting. Thanks for sharing.
Hi there friend! Thanks for the kind words…and every once in a while I get lucky at a thrift store! But I’m not very consistent at browsing, think I’d have better luck if I went more regularly.
Have a great week.
Hugs, Lynn
Thanks for this. I’m in the mood to find a good board now. I’ve always been weary of buying a used board, and then you come along with this. I can’t wait to find one.
Hey Lynne…have fun thrifting! I’m definitely going to be looking for more. It was a fun and quick project to take it from quite yucky to lovely.
Wishing you a wonderful weekend my friend.
Hugs, Lynn
You make the restoring process look easy! I love how it has little legs on the bottom. Thanks for sharing.
It really was so easy…rather immediate gratification…which is always good. I do love those little feet too. Thanks so much for swinging by and leaving your kind comment. I do hope you enjoy a lovely weekend my friend.
Hugs, Lynn
Beautiful, wow you were lucky! I love that it’s so thick and is standing! It really even can be used in many ways if you, one day want to have it as a plant stand or base of a centerpiece… so many ideas! Your meat and cheese dinner looks delicious on it though and btw. we have that dinner many evenings, it’s my favourite! Have a lovely weekend Lynn!
Hey there friend! I do love a meat and cheese dinner…would imagine that is rather common in Spain! I do love that cutting board…still trying to figure out where it’s going to ‘live’ in my kitchen but you are right…so many use.
Have a lovely weekend my friend.
Hugs, Lynn
Lynn this is definitely a keeper. Your board and the post on how to restore it. Many times we get things and we don’t know the history so we just relegate it for other uses. I’m glad you can use this board as it was meant to be.
Great find indeed! I love how you restored it. I think a huge knife for sure was placed on the bottom. Great work!
What a fabulous find Lynn! And boy did it come up well!! Love it!
I have an Acacia wood cutting board that I’ve had for 15 years now. The oil I got at walmart was too watery and didn’t work well. I got the butchers block oil from Ironwood ( https://www.ironwoodgourmet.com ) and it worked great for me. It brought the color of the board back. Just buy butchers block oil anywhere that’s decent.
Thanks so much for your input Hermione! I do think that a good butcher block oil makes a difference…sometimes you really do get what you pay for! I don’t have an acacia wood cutting board, but they sure are beautiful.
Have a great day my friend.
Hugs, Lynn
Isn’t mineral oil a good conditioner?
Absolutely…mineral oil works well too!
Hi Lynn, Like many others, I came across your website while searching for knit dishcloth patterns. And along with finding those patterns, I discovered your wonderful weekly newsletter of all sorts of interesting tips and projects, one of them being how to restore a wood cutting board. I had always been intrigued with restoring a board but was reluctant, not knowing what it may have been used for in the past. Luckily I found one at my local thrift shop and although not as unique as yours, it was exactly what I was searching for. The hydrogen peroxide worked like a charm. My daughter is thrilled with it and my husband wanted to keep it. Thanks so much for sharing the dishcloth patterns but mostly for your weekly emails which helped to keep me sane during these pandemic lockdowns.
Hi again Mary!
Sounds like you need to find another cutting board at the thrift store! And it sounds like I need to accompany you on your thrifting forays! Linen napkins and a lovely cutting board! I found my cutting board at a thrift store, but my batting average finding good stuff is otherwise very low! Do you go to Goodwill and Habitat ReStores? I think I need to go more often; I seem to wait until I am looking for something particular and then never find it.
And my heart is happy that I helped keep you busy during the pandemic. I do love this wee job of mine, but it all themore rewarding when I know I am actually doing what I set out to do.
Have a beautiful Sunday!
Hugs,
Lynn
Looking at the underside of your block I’d say it’s a slot for a meat cleaver rather than a knife. Your saved item is nice and your explanation is appreciated.
Thanks Buddy! That makes a lot of sense! And I appreciate the kind feedback. Have a wonderful day.
Hugs,
Lynn